ROTK extended DVD will be out in  JAN 30 2004

ROTK extended DVD will be out in November and will run 4 hours and 10 minutes.

There are 14 reader comments

SmartAss29 30 2004 9:29AM

Great. Perhaps he can add 4 or 5 more endings to the Never Ending Movie.

SmartAss43 30 2004 9:43AM

Now, before everyone gives me shit, I'm a big fan of Jackson (Peter not Michael) and I did an all day Triology Marathon when I went to see ROTK. But let me tell you, an audible groan went through the audience after the second fade out (fade outs or white outs - I forget which - there were so many). The next ending was greeted by some giggling and the audience wasn't quite sure when to finally clap, like the ending off an overbearing symphony, with crescendo after crescendo to the bitter end. Gotta admit, I liked some endings better than others, but thought the Director should have had some more back bone. Perhaps my only major complaint, but I was left a little unsastisfied by so many Hollywood Happy endings tacked on to a what I thought was a great movie trilogy. (Now, come on, even you diehard fans, have to admit the scene of Sam, wife and kids was a bit treacly, almost Color Purple Spielburgian.)

Andrew02 30 200410:02AM

Now, come on, even you diehard fans, have to admit the scene of Sam, wife and kids was a bit treacly, almost Color Purple Spielburgian.

And practically word for word from the novel.

unmute27 30 200410:27AM

alas, more proof of my retardation. i left after the first ending. but maybe that was foolishly wise, as i left satisfied and with a sense of closure.

i'll watch the other 31 endings on the extended dvd.

E.T.20 30 2004 1:20PM

My movie was better.

jay29 30 2004 1:29PM

endings are great as is. after a 10+hr epic, i think its nice to see some closure. which endings could you all have done without?

Scott00 30 2004 2:00PM

I will be interested in seeing it 'as intended'. However I still don't think it will win the Best Picture Oscar. Long rant why here.

Plus, I'm still disappointed that there will be no 'scouring of the Shire'.

Mike05 30 2004 2:05PM

Boy, that "too many endings" bandwagon has legs. Fewer people would have even noticed that Jackson not used fade-outs between each one.

Me? I wanted more endings.

dowingba23 30 2004 2:23PM

Plus, I'm still disappointed that there will be no 'scouring of the Shire'.

Oh my, that would have sent audiences fleeing away screaming in droves. I didn't find the movie too fatiguing, but can you imagine after all that, they start yet another battle sequence? Even I couldn't take that.

Stefan Jones59 30 2004 2:59PM

I've heard that the 14-disc 10th Anniversary Edition LOTR set will include the 8mm test footage of Robin Williams as Tom Bombadil.

oster beep beep51 30 2004 4:51PM

4 hours and 10 minutes is about 4 hours too long. Hated it.

tom03 31 2004 1:03AM

Mike wrote:
Boy, that "too many endings" bandwagon has legs. Fewer people would have even noticed that Jackson not used fade-outs between each one.

The reason that bandwagon has legs: most people had to pee REAL bad by that point in the film. After that first fade-out, everyone was expecting credits and a rush to the urinals. 3+ hours and you expect us to hold the 2 liter of soda we polished off before they lit the signal fires?

Graham44 31 2004 9:44AM

I looked at all the people tanking up on overpriced Coke and popcorn before the movie, and I thought, "ha ha, suckers! You'll regret it later!"

Craniac16 31 200410:16AM

I thought the ending where Liv Tyler had a little fling with Gandalf and Aragorn became an overweight, alcoholic bureaucrat strayed too far from the original.

I'd like to see a free, opensource version of "moviemask" so people could make remix controller files and share them on the net. I'd love to see the trilogy condensed to 90 minutes.

This thread is closed to new comments. Thanks to everyone who responded.

kottke.org

Front page
About + contact
Site archives

Subscribe

Follow kottke.org on Twitter

Follow kottke.org on Tumblr

Like kottke.org on Facebook

Subscribe to the RSS feed

Advertisement

Ads by The Deck

Support kottke.org shop at Amazon

And more at Amazon.com

Looking for work?

More at We Work Remotely

Kottke @ Quarterly

Subscribe to Quarterly and get a real-life mailing from Jason every three months.

 

Enginehosting

Hosting provided EngineHosting