The 1,000 Best Movies Ever Made, compiled by the NY Times  JUN 23 2004

The 1,000 Best Movies Ever Made, compiled by the NY Times. I've seen 201 of these, which is impressive considering I generally don't like films made before 1970.

There are 20 reader comments

jkottke31 23 2004 4:31PM

I found this link on Alison's site, who has seen 123 of the movies on the list.

Jeremiah47 23 2004 4:47PM

I agree with most of them, but Gangs of New York and Shrek over the LOTR films? Blasphemy! Heh. At least Berardinelli lists them collectively in the top 50.

Nice list, though. I'd say I've seen about 200 or so myself. I'll probably use it as a handy guide for finding the good stuff--I've done the same with books.

Jeff05 23 2004 5:05PM

201?? Did you count by hand??

Kip Ingram40 23 2004 5:40PM

You edged me out, Jason. 197. Nice list; thanks for the link.

jojo23 23 2004 6:23PM

hmmm - definitely some great films missing from the list - notably those in multiple series-type films (where was alien, dr. no, empire strikes back, etc). I stopped counting the ones I'd seen when I got past 300 in the p's. Does that mean I watch too many movies? Damn my netflix and unlimited blockbuster accounts!

Good to see 4 david lynch films on there, though, which I would agree are his four best.

Buck Turgidson34 23 2004 6:34PM

No "Life of Brian"? No "Holy Grail"? You call this the BEST movies ever made?

sam47 23 2004 6:47PM

i think i've seen about 230, but i'm not sure how movies like donnie darko, braveheart, bottle rocket, memento, glengarry glen ross, lotr (1, 2 or 3) and coyote ugly (kidding) got left off the list.

mark50 23 2004 6:50PM

First, Die Hard in the best 1000 films ever? Yippie-ki-aye indeed...

Second, you generally don't like films before 1970? That's probably why Die Hard is on the list.


phil15 23 2004 7:15PM

i didn't get to play outside much as a kid, i've seen at least 360 that i recognize.

julie42 23 2004 7:42PM

damn. only seen 198, but own 30 on DVD alone (not counting the old VHS's I've got stacked up). Looks like I'll have to stop wasting my time watching the Punky Brewster series and AbFab on DVD and update my Netflix queue with more "quality" titles to get up to speed.

Tom28 23 200410:28PM

It would be good if they provided a checkbox next to each entry that would tally the # of movies you have seen.

Hitchcock's thirty-nine steps is a great one.

Kip Ingram30 23 200410:30PM

Well, since Die Hard seems to be getting peoples attention let me wade right in and say yes, it was a great movie. One of the best action movies ever. And remember, this is a list of the top *1000* movies, not the top *100*. And Aliens was much, *much* better than Alien (and the rest of the series sucked).

Julie, no doubt. I'm a Netflix member and suddenly there's more grist for the mill.

finn07 23 200411:07PM

considering I generally don't like films made before 1970.

Philistine!

279 for me.

there are a number of dubious choices which seem to have been made because of the impact, cultural resonance, or wide popularity of the film rather than the fact that it's one of the "best", but still a pretty good list.

Stefan Jones23 24 200412:23AM

Heh. I'm still working on a Ten Best list I clipped out of the SF Chron a few years back. It's taken me two years to see all but 7.

Working through this list would take decades unless I seriously change my habits.

karen34 24 200412:34AM

They put the Flamingo Kid twice. It wasn't THAT good!

mark21 24 2004 5:21AM

Shawshank Redemption - THAT was a good film. No mention. Boo.

barnes22 24 2004 9:22AM

Adjusting for the duplication of the Flamingo Kid and Ashes and Diamonds, the list actually has 1,004 entries.

nkw16 24 200410:16AM

263 for me. When I saw "Total Recall" on the list, I was very surprised. If you're going to include *one* Schwarzenegger film on this list, make it "The Terminator". Putting more than one Paul Verhoeven film (Total Recall, Robocop) smacks of Dutch director bias ;-)

Julie02 24 2004 2:02PM

263 for me too. My mother and I used to watch a lot of old movies when I was young, and now I watch on average about four or five movies a week. Most of my favourites aren't on that list, although I was pleased to see Ponette on there - highly recommended.

John28 24 2004 5:28PM

Definitely missing:

1. The Lord of the Rings
2. The Life of Brian
3. Matrix
4. Metropolis
5. Ferris Bueller's Day Off
6. Ghostbusters
7. Zardoz
8. Ali

Well, my taste...

This thread is closed to new comments. Thanks to everyone who responded.

this is kottke.org

   Front page
   About + contact
   Site archives

You can follow kottke.org on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, Feedly, or RSS.

Ad from The Deck

We Work Remotely

 

Enginehosting

Hosting provided EngineHosting