There are 9 reader comments
28 16 2003 5:28PM
If these things were implicit, there wouldn't be a need or a demand for licenses such as these.
38 16 200311:38PM
They're actually explicitly disallowed. Changing the law to make them implicit isn't a possibility with Valenti and Co. around, and probably shouldn't be done anyway. Short of putting stuff in the public domain, it looks like a pretty good solution.
18 17 2003 9:18PM
there are two concerns, practical and legal.
practically, adding the creative commons license doesn't make a difference. people who're going to do it are going to do it anyway.
thus, i think you're talking about legally. it is still dubious on this ground. GPU, the computer programming equivalent of creative common licenses, are being challenged in court right now as having no legal authority. (SCO vs. IBM) so i think that may not be all that useful either.
17 18 2003 2:17AM
What are you on about? You're allowed to give anyone any rights to your work. The SCO case rests on very, very shaky legal grounds.
You can sample anyone's work as long as you license it or it remains within fair use bounds. This CC license is a way for creators to say, 'ok, I've given you the license' without having each person ask for it.
Those people who were going to "do it anyway" would get sued if they sampled under normal copyright. They don't if the work has a CC-sampling license.
30 18 2003 1:30PM
Sued by whom? If the creator is okay with the sampling, then they would not be sued. I am saying that the same effect can be achieved by simply having a line on your website that says "feel free to sample this..." instead of this branding thing.
52 18 2003 5:52PM
convinced! i will rescind my creative commons license right away! its too shaky! I WILL NEVER MAKE MONEY BY ALLOWING PEOPLE TO TAKE FREELY AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
25 18 2003 9:25PM
I am saying that the same effect can be achieved by simply having a line on your website that says "feel free to sample this..." instead of this branding thing.
True. I see your point. But I guess it always helps to have a unified language :)
32 18 2004 7:32PM
Please allow me to leave my links on your page
Married Women Cheating Wives
Swingers Clubs
Swingers Couples Swinging
Swinger Couples ads
Penis Growth Pills
Sorry for disturbing
Regards
This thread is closed to new comments. Thanks to everyone who responded.
Jonas!28 16 200311:28AM
i like the things that creative commons do, but i also feel it's a waste of time. these things should be implicit, and there's no need to brand it under this umbrella.